I do have to concur with Lisa on this. My own characters have barely interacted with his, but from just looking, I also feel that at the moment, Jay is "that one obviously bisexual at the least guy who calls everyone sugar and honey". It seems stereotypical and one-note to me.

TD;LR: seeing more layers of the cake would be more delicious than getting sick on just the icing. And now you all want cake. My work is done.